Pros and Cons of V Tail

Pros and Cons of V Tail

V-tail is the arrangement of aircraft tail control surfaces. V-tail replaces the traditional fin and horizontal surfaces with two surfaces which forms a V-shape configuration. The aircraft has the same stabilizing forces like conventional tail system

This article highlights the pros and cons of using a V-tail configuration.

Pros:

1. Lighter: V-tail designed aircraft is lighter compared to the conventional tail configuration of other aircraft designs. The under-sized surfaces used in designing the V-tail makes it lighter and faster. The configuration has few surfaces than the conventional T-tail system.

2. Surface area: V-tail design have a less wetted surface area as it has only two control surfaces compared to conventional aircraft which have three.

3. Reduced drag: Reducing intersection surfaces from three to two leads to the reduction in drag as it eliminates interference drag.

4. Reduces wear: To avoid placing the vertical stabilizer in the engine exhaust, a V-tail configuration is used. This ensures the flow of the exhaust is not disrupted and also reduces the wear on the stabilizer.

5. Increase stealth: The canted surfaces of V-tail configuration reflect radar away from the source leading to increased stealth.

6. Reduce infrared signature: V-tail design allows the engine to be mounted above the fuselage. This helps reduce infrared signature from below.

7. Improve safety: Placing the engine above the fuselage, it not only reduce infrared signature but also improve the safety of the aircraft and reduce cabin noise.

8. Better span: A properly sized V-tail have the same wetted area as conventional tail systems. It leads to better span since the area is spread over two surfaces instead of three.

9. Optimize fuselage: V-tail allows you to optimize the aircraft fuselage and put the aircraft mass lower than T-tail. This makes the aircraft more damage resistance.

10. Different options: V-tails are either all-flying or removable allowing you to choose one based on your preferences.

 

Cons:

1. Cause Snaking: To prevent snaking/yawing, V-tail aircraft need to have a longer rear fuselage compared to the conventional empennages.

2. Induced drag: Making some certain movements during the landing of the aircraft, may cause some induced drag. The right rudder aircraft can yaw right and vice versa,

3. Complex control system: V-tail aircraft configurations require complex control system since the two surfaces of the design have to move together and this can be a bit challenging to pilots used to flying conventional aircraft.

4. Increased load: More load is required to design a robust aircraft compared to designing a conventional system.

5. Require more control forces: V-tail aircraft system requires a lot of control forces in order to effectively operate the aircraft. This makes it difficult for the aircraft to be flown by just any pilot. V-tail designs need a lot of control.

6. Constant fiddling: When using radar in a thermal turn, sometimes the V-tail keep on stalling and you have to keep fiddling it to have the right differential. If not fixed, it can cause some “up’ elevator effect.

7. Not full flying: V-tails are not full-flying if you’re looking for decalage.

8. Unstable: If the V-tail has the same size of stab + elevator at the top view and the same size in the side view with fin + rudder, then this causes an undersized V-tail and poor stability.

9. Failure tolerance: In V-tail design, it is difficult to maneuver the aircraft if one of the lifting surfaces has issues or malfunctions.

10. Less control surface: In V-tail, there is no control surface which is directly proportional to the desired force vector used in pitching.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.